1999
Matt Barger
Greenwood, Ind. |
| 
2000
Ross Flannagan
Jasper, Ind. |
| 
2001
Kari Schultz
Winamac, Ind. |
2003
Sarah Hagerty
Richland City, Ind.
| 
2004
Marni Smith
Indianapolis, Ind. | 
2005
Jessica Bentley
Anderson, Ind. |
2006
Bethany Overdorf
Noblesville, Ind.
| 
2007
Susie Leigh Smith
Corydon, Ind.
| 
2008
Stephanie Pitman
Frankfort, Ind. |