1999
Allan Earl
Frankfort, Ind. |
| 
2000
Hannah Johnson
Rolling Prairie, Ind. |
| 
2001
Lori Uebelhor
Ferdinand, Ind. |
2002
Mitchell Jackson
Thorntown, Ind.
| 
2003
Cody Michel
North Manchester, Ind. | 
2004
Delaney McGrath
Indianapolis, Ind. |
 2005
Devin
Achenbach
Indianapolis, Ind.
| 
2006
Kristin
Speer
West
Lafayette, Ind.
| 
2007
Mara Schroering
Celestine, Ind. |
2008
Marah
Smelser,
Lafayette, Ind.
| 
2009
Emma Schroeder
Kendallville, Ind.
| 
2010
Shelby Pieper
Springville, Ind. |